Married At First Sight Season 15: None Of The Couples Lasted (Why Did Each Break Up?)

Summary All couples from Married at First Sight season 15 broke up, with each pair having their own reasons for splitting.

Morgan and Binh's marriage fell apart during the honeymoon after Binh made false allegations and broke Morgan's trust.

Stacia and Nate seemed compatible but ultimately divorced due to disagreements over starting a family and cohabitating.

The couples of Married at First Sight season 15 have all broken up, and each pair had their own reasons for splitting. The fifteenth season of the hit Lifetime reality TV show took place in San Diego and highlighted five couples who married each other at the altar sight unseen. Season 15 started airing in July 2022, and was likely filmed in late 2021 and early 2022. The participants had been through lengthy questionnaires and interviews before being chosen to come on the show. All the cast members led with their strong desire to start a marriage and begin partnerships.

During Married at First Sight season 15, Morgan Bell and Binh Trinh didn't even make it to Decision Day and broke up well before. Lindy Elloway and Miguel Santiago-Medina, Stacia Karcher and Nate Barnes, Mitch Silverstein and Krysten Collins, and Justin Hall and Alexis Williams all put in the work to get to Decision Day. However, some were over by the time the Reunion was filmed, and some ended their marriages after all filming for the season concluded. The demise of all the season 15 marriages contributed to the show's 18.75% success rate since it premiered in 2014.

Related 20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.

Morgan Bell and Binh Trinh

Only The Beginning Was Happy

Binh and Morgan's relationship got off to a rough start after Binh tested positive for COVID-19 before their wedding day. Their wedding and their ability to join the other couples on the honeymoon got delayed. Morgan and Binh seemed to have instant chemistry at the altar, with Morgan remarking about how attractive she found Binh.

While Morgan stayed supportive about the delay and was happy after seeing Binh at the end of the aisle, things fell apart during the honeymoon. Binh told his closest cast mate Justin that Morgan wasn't a real nurse, and Binh's claim made its way back to Morgan and she confronted Binh.

Morgan said the claim was untrue, hurtful, potentially damaging, and that the allegation betrayed her trust.

When specifically told by Morgan not to share their personal information with Justin, Binh continued. He talked to Justin about the disconnect he and Morgan were having, which was overheard by Alexis and reported back to Morgan. Morgan's confidence in her marriage completely left, and she asked for a divorce based on a lack of trust (via Lifetime.) Morgan gained a bad reputation on the show through Married at First Sight viewer opinion for being too harsh on Binh and not giving the marriage a fair chance because she checked out so soon.

Lindy Elloway and Miguel Santiago-Medina

Lindy & Miguel Couldn't Overcome Problems

Lindy and Miguel were the most recent couple to get divorced, which is sad because they had the most hope and positivity during the Reunion. During the season, Lindy and Miguel had problems with impatience and the couple had misunderstandings, like with Lindy being upset Miguel wouldn't put her on his insurance. But the pair were confident enough in their ability to overcome things by Decision Day. Unfortunately, in mid-February 2023, Lindy announced on Instagram that they had split.

"It's impossible to stay married if both parties are not equally committed to the marriage's success," Lindy wrote.

Stacia Karcher and Nate Barnes

Stacia & Nate Shared An Entreprenuerial Spirit

Close

Stacia and Nate seemed like the most compatible couple in Married at First Sight season 15. They were both driven, successful individuals with great physical chemistry. They said yes to each other on Decision Day and were still a couple at the Reunion. However, Stacia filed for divorce in December 2022.

She explained, "Everything that he agreed to do on the show were all words. There was no action."

On the show, the pair had disagreements over when to start a family and how to cohabitate, issues which seem to have ultimately contributed to their marriage's demise. They never ended up officially moving in together after Decision Day as they had planned.

Mitch Silverstein and Krysten Collins

Mitch & Krysten's Marriage Caused Explosive Moments

Krysten and Mitch's relationship during the season was the most tense and created many of the most spicy moments. Mitch put his foot in his mouth a lot when it came to his attraction to Krysten, and it became clear she was not the kind of woman Mitch was looking for. Krysten tried not to hold resentment and aimed to build their foundation. They even decided to consummate their marriage, and Krysten tried to assimilate into Mitch's rigid environmentalist lifestyle.

However, Krysten's feelings of being disrespected and not valued enough ultimately led to an even bigger blow up in front of the experts and the rest of the couples, where she slammed the experts' interpretations of her feelings and let Mitch have it about saying she wasn't attractive to him (via Lifetime.) Their increasingly tense marriage due to Krysten feeling undervalued led to her saying no come Decision Day. Mitch also said no, but the pair left the season amicably.

Justin Hall and Alexis Williams

Justin & Alexis Were Never On The Same Page

Close

Justin and Alexis had perhaps the strangest marriage of Married at First Sight season 15. Justin came in hot, dropping the L word in the first few days of his honeymoon with Alexis. And once he said it, he had no problem continuing to say it on the honeymoon. It took Alexis a while to reciprocate, but she eventually did.

The pair faced issues over Justin's dog attacking Alexis' dog, which led to Justin having to give up his dog and feeling resentment toward Alexis for having him part ways with his beloved animal.

Moreover, the pair had many emotional differences, with Justin being hypersensitive and a poor communicator and Alexis being blunt and analytical.

They also got into a notable and continued argument about Alexis wanting to still have girl's nights and go out to clubs. Justin felt that was inappropriate, and Alexis thought he was just trying to control her.

Despite all the negative interactions, Justin and Alexis said yes on Decision Day. However, they revealed they split during the Reunion. The Married at First Sight season 15 couple split because Alexis was never truly in love with Justin and wanted a more dominant partner, while Justin said disagreed with Alexis' lifestyle.

Married at First Sight seasons 1-17 are available on Amazon.

Source: Lifetime/YouTube, Lifetime/YouTube