Why Rebel Moon 2's Rotten Tomatoes Critics & Audience Scores Are So Divided

Summary Zack Snyder's Rebel Moon 2 has a mixed reception, with critics slamming the narrative but audiences enjoying the action and entertainment value.

Rebel Moon 2's 54% audience score reflects Snyder's dedicated fan base, while the 17% Rotten Tomatoes score highlights criticism of the poorly constructed narrative.

Snyder's divisive movies consistently see higher audience scores than critic ratings, with his popularity surging after his director's cut of Justice League.

Zack Snyder's latest film, Rebel Moon - Part Two: The Scargiver, is out on Netflix, and it's received a divisive response from audiences and critics. For two decades, Zack Snyder has been making high-budget, violent, stylized action movies, with his distinct aesthetic becoming one of cinema's most recognizable and controversial. While almost anyone can admit his films have some of the most impressive visuals in their respective genres, his relentless action can be jarring, and his movie scripts are often the prime target of criticism, leading to commonly mixed reactions.

Rebel Moon 2 is now available to stream on Netflix.

That said, Snyder's Rebel Moon movies have some of his worst critic scores yet. There are several reasons for Rebel Moon 2's poor reviews, but the most fascinating part of the film's reception is the differing audience score. Currently, Rebel Moon 2 has a 17% score on Rotten Tomatoes and a 54% score from audiences. It's not an enormous improvement, but it's enough to raise questions about the varying perceptions determining these numbers.

Your browser does not support the video tag.

What Audiences Like About Zack Snyder's Rebel Moon: Part 2

Rebel Moon 2's 54% Audience Score Is Due To Its Action & Entertainment Value

Close

There are two main reasons for Zack Snyder's Rebel Moon 2 having a far more decent audience reception and critic score. Obviously, 54% isn't anything to write home about, but it demonstrates a pool of viewers leaning toward the high-end scores, many even giving the film 5/5 stars. This reception is typical for Snyder's movies, as he has one of the most dedicated and passionate fan bases in cinema. There is undoubtedly a significant number of movie fans who adore Zack Snyder's style and fully support his vision, with praise for his new sci-fi saga.

Related Rebel Moon 2's Abysmal Rotten Tomatoes Score Proves Netflix Is Focused On The Wrong Zack Snyder Franchise After seeing Rebel Moon 2's abysmal Rotten Tomatoes score, it is hard not to believe that Netflix is invested in the wrong Zack Snyder movie franchise

The other notable factor is that movies released on streaming typically have a lower bar for their audience scores. Many of Netflix's most-watched movies are action films with low critic scores, as stay-at-home entertainment value is held to a different standard than theatrical releases. Streaming releases can earn decent audience scores from general audiences by being fun enough, having some exciting action, and being an enjoyable films to turn the brain off to. On Letterboxd, which shows a score from audiences who are generally more passionate and selective about movies, it only has 2/5 stars.

Why Rebel Moon 2's Rotten Tomatoes Critics Score Is So Low

Rebel Moon 2's 17% Tomatometer Is Due To Its Poorly Constructed Narrative & Dialogue

Custom image by Ryan Northrup

Reviews of Rebel Moon 2 were far harsher than audiences, giving Zack Snyder the lowest score of his career. ScreenRant's Rebel Moon 2 Review gave the film 2/5 stars, with one of the main cons being that "There's no emotional connection or investment in the characters." This is a consistent opinion among many reviews, who focused on the film's dialogue as its primary flaw. Rebel Moon 2 assembles a team of heroes, much like Star Wars, but they largely lack distinct personalities outside of their weapon skills, with much of their lines focused on providing exposition for the movie.

Related Rebel Moon Part 2 Ending Explained Zack Snyder's Rebel Moon - Part Two: The Scargiver sees the rebels fight back against the Imperium, while the ending sets up a future adventure.

Many critics praised Snyder's world-building and visuals as one of the movie's best qualities but stressed that the narrative is subpar. MovieWeb gave Rebel Moon 2 a more positive review but compared the film to one of its main inspirations, saying, "The film is still just a rehash of Seven Samurai and is very predictable." There are some compelling elements tossed in around the two-hour space opera, but the story structure is pretty generic and uninspired, filled with narrative and character archetype clichés.

Your browser does not support the video tag.

Rebel Moon 2's Rotten Tomatoes Split Happens With Every Zack Snyder Movie

Zack Snyder's Filmography Has Consistently Been Met With Divisive Reactions

Close

Looking at Zack Snyder's filmography, every single movie he's made has seen a higher audience score than Tomatometer, with the differential widening more over time. Zack Snyder's popularity surged in the years following Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, especially after the film's special edition director's cut vastly improved upon the theatrical release. In the 2010s, when Marvel movies dominated box offices, Snyder stood out by offering a more subversive take on superhero movies, leading to the enormous movement to support his director's cut of Justice League.

Zack Snyder Movies Movie Tomatometer Audience Score Rebel Moon 2 17% 54% Rebel Moon 1 21% 58% Zack Snyder's Justice League 72% 93% Batman v Superman 29% 63% Man of Steel 56% 75%

The concept of the director's cut has become a common topic surrounding his films, with Netflix suggesting they'd be releasing alternate R-rated cuts of Rebel Moon. It's possible that the lower critical scores on his recent movies are tied to a frustration with the sensation surrounding his work, as the initial releases of Rebel Moon seem frivolous when an improved director's cut was already announced. Still, there are plenty of valid reasons to criticize Rebel Moon 2; seeing how the vernacular discourse plays into his film's reception is fascinating.

Sources: MovieWeb