Mark Hamill's Seven Live-Action Star Wars Stories, Ranked From Best To Worst

April 23, 2024, 3 p.m.

Movies

Mark Hamill's Seven Live-Action Star Wars Stories, Ranked From Best To Worst

0 0

Summary Hamill's portrayal of Luke Skywalker has been consistently brilliant despite being in higher and lower-ranked Star Wars properties.

Hamill's appearances in The Mandalorian, The Book of Boba Fett, and The Rise of Skywalker rank lower due to their lack of emotional depth, the brevity of the roles, and CGI hang-ups.

Mark Hamill's best performances as Luke Skywalker come in The Last Jedi, The Empire Strikes Back, and Return of the Jedi, showcasing the character's growth and emotional depth.

Mark Hamill has played Luke Skywalker in seven live-action Star Wars projects, some better than others. Since 1977, Hamill has been one of the faces of the Star Wars franchise. Each Star Wars trilogy includes the character of Luke Skywalker in some capacity, with Hamill portraying the character in five feature films. Hamill has also played Luke Skywalker on the small screen, something that has been theorized to continue in upcoming Star Wars TV shows.

Mark Hamill's Live-Action Star Wars Appearances Title Release Date Rotten Tomatoes Score Star Wars May 25, 1977 93% The Empire Strikes Back May 21, 1980 95% Return of the Jedi May 25, 1983 83% Star Wars: The Last Jedi December 15, 2017 91% Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker December 16, 2019 51% The Mandalorian season 2, episode 8 December 18, 2020 90% The Book of Boba Fett episodes 5 & 6 January 26 & February 2, 2022 66%

With such a wide-reaching resume within a galaxy far, far away, Hamill's appearances as Skywalker naturally encompass the best and worst of Star Wars movies, storylines, and character depictions. When concerning how Hamill's Luke Skywalker appearances rank against one another, however, it is worth noting that this list does not reflect the quality of the individual films or shows. Hamill's character and performances have changed significantly from project to project and are ranked against one another individually, regardless of how strong or weak the project itself is.

Related How Old Was Mark Hamill In Every Star Wars Movie & TV Show? Mark Hamill has portrayed the iconic Luke Skywalker for over 40 years, and he has aged and grown alongside his character through it all.

7 Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker

Hamill's final film appearance ranks lowest due to brevity.

Unfortunately, Hamill's role in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker should have been more impactful than it was given it is the final film in the Skywalker Saga. Hamill's appearance in the film comes midway through the story as Rey flees to Ahch-To upon finding out that Palpatine is her grandfather. Luke appears to give Rey a pre-third act pep-talk, convincing her to forsake her bloodline and fight back against Palpatine in the name of the Jedi.

Hamill also appeared in an eighth live-action project, yet his cameo in Star Wars: The Force Awakens is simply not long enough to judge thoroughly.

The scene undoubtedly works as a satisfying story point, as it makes sense for Luke - after the lessons he learned in Star Wars: The Last Jedi - to push Rey away from Ahch-To. Similarly, seeing Luke finally lift an X-Wing out of the water after he failed to in The Empire Strikes Back is a wonderful callback. However, the scene is only brief, and Luke's only other appearance comes in the final shot of the film. For this lack of depth and nothing else, Hamill's appearance in The Rise of Skywalker ranks lowest among his seven in live-action Star Wars.

6 The Mandalorian Season 2

Luke Skywalker's Mandalorian appearance is exciting and action-packed but lacks substance.

While still a fantastic cameo, Mark Hamill's appearance in The Mandalorian season 2 is the second-weakest of the actor's seven live-action roles. Concerning positives, the scene makes for one of the most exciting, pure fan-service moments in the show's entire run. The slow build-up of seeing a lone X-Wing appear to save Din Djarin and his crew, the cloaked figure, the green lightsaber, and then the final reveal of a de-aged Mark Hamill is a masterclass in tension building. Combined with Ludwig Goransson's fantastic musical score and brilliant action, the scene works unequivocally for pure visceral thrills.

Related Luke Skywalker In The Mandalorian Explained: Jedi Order & Baby Yoda Future Luke Skywalker trains Grogu between The Mandalorian season 2 and The Book of Boba Fett, but what does this mean for the Jedi Order and its future?

However, Hamill's appearance ranks low on this list because of the lack of the scene's emotional weight, at least in comparison to the other entries. While it still works within the context of the story, Skywalker's appearance applies more to fan service than satisfying storytelling. Also, the de-aging effect is notably distracting, making it difficult to connect emotionally with Luke. Finally, Hamill's appearance in The Mandalorian season 2 was retroactively harmed by Grogu returning to Din in The Book of Boba Fett. As a result, any remaining feeling of emotional weight the scene did have has since been stripped away.

Max Lloyd-Jones served as the body double for Luke Skywalker in The Mandalorian season 2, though Hamill was also on set.

The Mandalorian Where to Watch *Availability in US stream

rent

buy Not available Not available Not available The Mandalorian is set after the Empire's fall and before the First Order's emergence in the ever-growing Star Wars universe. The series follows the travails of a lone gunfighter named Din Djarin (Pedro Pascal) in the outer reaches of the galaxy, far from the authority of the New Republic. Acting as the first live-action Star Wars series, The Mandalorian has become incredibly popular on Disney+, partly due to Mando’s relationship with Grogu, which the internet dubbed “Baby Yoda” upon his introduction in season 1. Cast Werner Herzog , Emily Swallow , Pedro Pascal , Nick Nolte , Omid Abtahi , Gina Carano , Carl Weathers , Giancarlo Esposito Writers Jon Favreau Directors Jon Favreau , Taika Waititi , Bryce Dallas Howard Showrunner Jon Favreau

5 The Book of Boba Fett

Luke's appearance alongside Grogu has more weight to it than his Mandalorian cameo.

Going hand-in-hand with Hamill's appearance in The Mandalorian is his role in The Book of Boba Fett episodes 5 and 6. As alluded to, this appearance cannot rank any higher due to the unfortunate adverse effect it had on The Mandalorian season 2. Luke and Grogu's story being crammed into The Book of Boba Fett made the stories of both The Mandalorian season 2 and The Mandalorian season 3 suffer as it deserved to be part of the latter show as opposed to the former, meaning it cannot rank higher than the projects above it.

That said, Hamill's role in The Book of Boba Fett stands above The Mandalorian and The Rise of Skywalker due to his extended appearance, stronger emotional throughline, and satisfying fan-service elements that ties Star Wars' New Republic timeline to that of the sequel trilogy. The longer role of Hamill in the show allows Luke to have more of a storyline than he did in The Mandalorian. Exploring vital Star Wars footnotes such as the New Republic Jedi Order, Luke's Jedi Temple, and his mistakes that ultimately led to the rise of Kylo Ren means the role has much more depth.

Another improvement over the appearance in The Mandalorian is The Book of Boba Fett's remarkable CGI upgrade. While it is somewhat distracting that Luke is rarely on-screen when speaking, the overall effect is much more impressive and, thus, much less jarring from an emotional standpoint. Combined with the overwhelmingly satisfying scene that saw Mark Hamill's Luke Skywalker meet Ahsoka Tano, and The Book of Boba Fett's Hamill appearance ranks above The Mandalorian and The Rise of Skywalker as his fifth-best in the Star Wars franchise.

4 Star Wars (A New Hope)

Hamill's first Star Wars appearance marks the first truly great entry on this list.

From this point onwards, all of Mark Hamill's Star Wars appearances have been great to fantastic to near-flawless. The first of these is the role that started it all: Mark Hamill's Luke Skywalker appearance in 1977's Star Wars. As does not need explaining, Hamill served as a brilliant, fresh-faced protagonist in Lucas' first Star Wars movie. Luke's humble background, the hints at his larger destiny, and Hamill's endearing performance make Luke easy to invest in, as does his emotional story of an orphaned farm boy taking on a tyrannical Empire.

Luke always strives to do the right thing, whether it be staying on the farm to help Owen and Beru, rescuing Leia, or fighting in the death-defying Battle of Yavin.

One of the primary reasons why Hamill's performance works so well is the way he imbues Luke with a sense of righteousness. Luke always strives to do the right thing, whether it be staying on the farm to help Owen and Beru, rescuing Leia, or fighting in the death-defying Battle of Yavin. While Luke's somewhat whiny tendencies and unexplained power - at least at the time concerning Star Wars' release order - mean Hamill's role in A New Hope cannot rank any higher, the film is a fantastic introductory showcase for one of the franchise's greatest characters.

3 Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Luke Skywalker's most divisive Star Wars story is also one of Mark Hamill's best performances.

The release of Star Wars: The Last Jedi in 2017 saw it become the most controversial film in the franchise to date. Arguably the biggest point of debate in the film was Luke Skywalker's arc, meaning it may be surprising to see this aspect ranked as the third-best of the character's franchise stories. Undoubtedly the biggest strength of Luke's Last Jedi story is Hamill's acting. Putting in one of the best acting performances in the entire franchise, Hamill nails the complex story of Luke's failure, depression, and redemption in one of the most raw, purely emotional turns in Star Wars.

Related Luke Skywalker's Death In Star Wars: The Last Jedi Was Perfect Many fans might think Luke Skywalker's Star Wars death in The Last Jedi was weak, but it was a poetically fitting end to the character's arc.

Another thing that helps Luke's story in Episode VIII stand above the others below it is the complex nature of his character. More so than any other film in the saga, The Last Jedi depicts Luke as a human being with flaws, doubts, fears, and failures. This culminates in one of the best Star Wars scenes ever crafted when Yoda tells Luke that failure is the most important thing to pass on to the next generation. If one thing ranks this performance down, it is The Last Jedi's neglect of showing Luke's deeper feelings about Han Solo's death.

Hamill's performance in The Last Jedi is even more impressive considering the actor did not care for the direction in which Luke was taken, yet performed perfectly regardless.

2 The Empire Strikes Back

Luke's journey of Jedi training holds the silver medal concerning Hamill's Star Wars roles.

When regarding iconicity, there is no denying that The Empire Strikes Back is one of Hamill's best stories in Star Wars. The film opens three years after A New Hope, immediately rectifying the slight mistake of its predecessor by giving Luke time to train. Rather than be a relatively lucky, overpowered farm boy, Luke is a confident, battle-tested hero of the Rebellion at the beginning of Empire. Luke's ease in destroying the Death Star is one of A New Hope's biggest issues, meaning this time jump is enough of a reason to rank Luke's Episode V story above Episode IV's.

Through Hamill's performance and Luke's journey, Star Wars audiences were introduced to key concepts...

Luke's story then takes this even further when he begins training with Yoda. Through Hamill's performance and Luke's journey, Star Wars audiences were introduced to key concepts like the Force, the Jedi, the dark side, and several other now-iconic elements of the franchise. All of this culminates in one of the biggest scenes in not just the Star Wars franchise, but cinematic history.

The final confrontation between Vader and Luke is driven by emotion, primarily from Hamill's performance. The reveal that Vader is Luke's father is iconic for a reason, with Hamill's performance aiding it in becoming a world-famous scene and one of Star Wars' best. Admittedly, there is little to pull Luke's story in The Empire Strikes Back down, aside from the forced love triangle between him, Leia, and Han that has since been made much weirder due to George Lucas' tweaking of Star Wars' Skywalker family tree.

1 Return of the Jedi

The weakest original trilogy film possesses Hamill's strongest Star Wars story as Luke Skywalker.

While Return of the Jedi is not as strong overall as A New Hope or The Empire Strikes Back, it undoubtedly features the best Luke Skywalker story in the entire saga. The appearance of Luke as a calculated and calm Jedi Master after his development in the prior two movies is a perfect culmination of his arc. Combined with a green lightsaber, fantastic action sequences, and his continued dedication to fighting the evil Empire, the basics of Luke's story in Return of the Jedi are as good, if not better, than the first two original trilogy movies.

Your browser does not support the video tag.

What helps set Hamill's story apart in Return of the Jedi is the connection Luke has with Vader and the development of the Skywalker family. The struggle between light and dark that permeates Luke's confrontation with Vader and Palpatine makes Return of the Jedi's final act one of the best in the saga, a feat that would not be possible without Luke. With the addition of his amazing scene with Leia, Luke's family troubles only improve after The Empire Strikes Back.

This all allows Return of the Jedi to satisfyingly end the original trilogy. Hamill's performance sells the emotion, turmoil, and pull of the dark side as he battles Vader, before transitioning into a heartbroken son when Anakin removes his helmet. This contrasts with the upbeat ending of Return of the Jedi's story to allow Hamill's performance to shine. With all of this ending the original trilogy on a high note, despite the film's overall drawbacks in the second act, Return of the Jedi is convincingly Hamill's best performance of his seven in live-action Star Wars.