Howl's Moving Castle's Original Director Would Have Changed Ghibli, & Anime History, Forever

Summary Director Mamoru Hasoda nearly led Howl's Moving Castle, but left due to creative differences.

Hasoda's departure allowed Miyazaki to infuse his distinct style into the film successfully.

Hasoda's different style suited his own projects more, showing the importance of artistic integrity.

Hayao Miyazaki's masterpiece Howl's Moving Castle is one of Studio Ghibli's most timeless and comforting films. The film has made history and continues to capture fan's hearts and earn new viewers, even two decades later. Howl's Moving Castle captures everything that makes Studio Ghibli films magical: the soothing music, the moving story, the lovable characters, and the pastel-toned and visually pleasing animation. However, few fans know that Mamoru Hasoda almost directed the movie.

After smash hit successes like My Neighbor Totoro in 1988 and Spirited Away in 2001, viewers were delighted to receive another extraordinary film from the groundbreaking Ghibli director. Most fans could not dream of Howl's Moving Castle being any different from the acclaimed classic they have grown to treasure, but surprisingly, the film could have gone in a vastly different direction. Miyazaki seems like the obvious choice for director, based on his long history of entertaining and heartwarming films with the company, but another experienced and critically acclaimed director, Mamoru Hasoda, was going to take on the project originally.

Mamoru Hasoda Almost Directed Howl's Moving Castle Instead of Hayao Miyazaki

Because of creative differences, the acclaimed director chose to leave the Ghibli project

Hasoda's resume is nothing to sneeze at, including films such as Summer Wars, Digimon: The Movie, One Piece: Baron Omatsuri And The Secret Island, and The Boy and the Beast. He has worked on projects for well-known franchises and undoubtedly made a name for himself in the anime film industry, explaining why Ghibli originally chose him for such an ambitious project. However, he quickly realized that his vision for the film did not match the intended mood and plot the studio had in mind. This is why he stepped down from being the director of the film, giving his place to Miyazaki.

As Hasoda explained in a Polygon interview:

“I was told to make [the movie] to similar to how Miyazaki would have made it, but I wanted to make my own film the way I wanted to make it."

Miyazaki had created a great number of films for Studio Ghibli at this point and thus, had established somewhat of a standard and tone for the movies that the studio hoped to continue with the creation of Howl's Moving Castle. Unfortunately, Hasoda's original storyboards and ideas did not mesh with what the Ghibli executives were envisioning, and so he parted ways with the film studio.

Related Howl's Moving Castle: 12 Small Details Fans May Have Missed From Sophie's curse to the castle itself, Howl's Moving Castle is full of small details that can be hard for fans to catch on a first viewing.

Hasoda's Style Differed Too Dramatically from the Studio Ghibli Feel

Hasoda's vision just did not meld with Studio Ghibli

Close

Although exact specifics of Hasoda's reasons for leaving Howl's Moving Castle have not been mentioned, he did explain why he chose to no longer work on the film. He reasoned that the difference between the film he wanted to do and how they wanted to do it was too great. No creative of any kind wants to feel stifled and held back from creating their art in the way they feel inspired to. It is for the best that Hasoda refused to conform to Ghibli's standards, as the resulting film would not have been as authentic as Miyazaki's version.

Hasoda's career in anime film directing did not end after his failed attempts at working on Howl's Moving Castle, rather, it flourished to new heights. The creator has enjoyed theatrical releases of his films and was even nominated for an Academy Award in 2019 for his film, Summer Wars. Hasoda's style of storytelling is markedly different from most typical Studio Ghibli films in a myriad of ways, so it is interesting to imagine how different both Hasoda's future career and Howl's Moving Castle itself would have turned out had he chosen to stay on the project instead of leaving early.

Hasoda and Miyazaki Have Very Different Ways to Tell Stories

Both creators have a trademark style that is entirely unique to them, and it is difficult to compare the two

Miyazaki was clearly the correct choice to direct Howl's Moving Castle, and the film was an immense success both financially and critically. The film was actually based on a novel by an author named Diana Wynne Jones. The book was published in 1986 and served as the inspiration for the acclaimed Studio Ghibli film that came a little less than two decades later. However, Miyazaki put his own twist on the beloved story and did not follow the source material exactly, freshening up the initial concept and adapting it to the screen fantastically and beautifully.

Miyazaki's style is characterized by gorgeous backdrops and worldbuilding that engrosses viewers in the same environment as the film's characters. His movies are all too easy to become fully immersed in, and he creates the type of characters that viewers fall in love with instantly. From adorable sidekicks like Fire Demon Calcifier and the cat Jiji, to powerful and relatable heroes like Howl and Sophie, the films are packed with top-notch character design. Hasoda is talented at these aspects of film creation as well, but he focuses more heavily on drama, emotionally charged moments, and the exploration of relationships between characters.

Related 10 Best Studio Ghibli Movies, According To Ranker From Spirited Away to Ponyo the stories, characters, and style of Studio Ghibli movies enchant viewers, but which do Ranker viewers find the best?

Miyazaki's Style Fits Howl's Moving Castle's Plot And Aesthetic Perfectly

It would be intriguing to watch a Hosoda-inspired version of the film

It is up to viewers which style they prefer, Hasoda's or Miyazaki's. However, it is difficult to compare the works of two different directors who don't share the same inspirations or intentions for their films. The beauty of art is that everyone's style is unique, and both creators deserve the acclaim they have received. Hasoda's choice to leave Studio Ghibli worked out in everyone's favor in the end. Miyazaki was able to create a beautiful, profound rendition of the story of Howl's Moving Castle, while Hasoda was able to pursue the creation of films that felt more genuine and true to him.

Source: Polygon