One Piece Season 2 Casting Supports A Long-Running Anime Theory About Zoro's Past

Summary Julia Rehwald's casting as Tashigi in One Piece season 2 ties back to Zoro's fascination with her resemblance to Kuina.

Netflix's Tashigi casting doubles down on the importance of Tashigi and Kuina's connection.

The ongoing debate about Tashigi and Kuina's similarity in One Piece hints at potential plot twists in future seasons.

There is more to Julia Rehwald's casting in One Piece season 2 than meets the eye. One Piece season 1's ending teased the arrival of the marines' Captain Smoker, and Callum Kerr has been cast in that iconic semi-villain role. Just as important as Smoker is his master chief petty officer, the sword-swinging Tashigi, and it's she that Rehwald will be playing when Netflix's live-action One Piece returns.

When the Straw Hats encounter Smoker in the One Piece anime and manga, Zoro is amazed by Tashigi's uncanny resemblance to Kuina, and this becomes a recurring theme whenever the two cross swords in later chapters. One Piece has never provided a concrete reason behind Tashigi's resemblance to Kuina, but a wave of fan theories have attempted to solve the mystery. One speculates that Tashigi and Kuina are somehow related; another suggests Kuina survived and adopted "Tashigi" as her new identity. One Piece season 2 looks set to weigh in upon that ongoing debate.

Related All 16 Netflix Live-Action Anime Adaptations, Ranked Worst To Best (Including One Piece) Netflix created a nearly perfect live-action anime adaptation with One Piece, and its history of failures and successes proves this was no easy task.

One Piece Season 2's Tashigi Actress Really Does Resemble Kuina

One Piece's Live-Action Casting Continues To Strike Gold

Close

In the One Piece anime and manga, the similarity between Tashigi and Kuina would not be immediately noticeable if Zoro didn't make a habit of mentioning it every time Smoker's unit cruised into view. Without Zoro, fans likely would have struggled to draw any connection between the two characters, but - to the Straw Hat swordsman, at least - Tashigi is the spitting image of what Kuina would have looked like if she hadn't died so young. Curiously, Julia Rehwald really does carry a passing resemblance to the actor who played live-action Kuina in One Piece season 1, Audrey Cymone.

The Tashigi-Kuina parallel is not a plot point Netflix's One Piece necessarily needed to adapt. Not only does it have minimal narrative impact, but finding a great Tashigi actor who could also be realistically compared to Audrey Cymone would have been a tough ask. Animation and manga can change any character's appearance with a pencil stroke, but real faces aren't quite so malleable, making live-action casting more restrictive. Nevertheless, One Piece has taken great effort to cast a Tashigi actress who looks vaguely like an older Kuina, suggesting Zoro, echoing the source material, will be mesmerized by Smoker's right-hand woman when they meet in season 2.

What One Piece Season 2's Casting Means For The Tashigi-Kuina Theories

Live-Action One Piece Doubles Down On The Connection's Importance

As of chapter #1120 in Eiichiro Oda's One Piece manga, a reason for Tashigi's resemblance to Kuina has not been given, and in 2009, the mangaka himself stated that Tashigi looking like Kuina was coincidental (via Shonen Jump). The possibility that one of the enduring theories will ultimately prove true does, however, remain possible. One Piece's creator hasn't always been beholden to his own comments, and after retconning Luffy's Devil Fruit and revealing the entire world is sinking, Kuina and Tashigi being the same person would barely crack the One Piece manga's top five most outlandish twists.

In a 2019 interview with Fischer's, Oda predicted that One Piece would end in 2024 - a claim that now looks incredibly unlikely. In a 2016 One Piece Great Newspaper interview, Oda suggested Luffy wouldn't beat Kaido with a simple strong punch, but that's exactly what happened when Luffy's victory came years later.

One Piece season 2 casting a Tashigi actor who bears a passing likeness to the actor who played Kuina doubles down on the importance of these characters being connected in some way. Netflix's live-action adaptation could have easily skipped over the Tashigi-Kuina mirroring, but has gone out of its way to retain that tricky aspect of the source material. Such a bold move only adds credence to the theories that claim Tashigi's similarities to Kuina are more than just coincidence.