Hollywood Desperately Needs To Remake This Disastrous '90s Sci-Fi Horror Movie Starring Marlon Brando

Summary The Island of Dr. Moreau (1996) faced setbacks from on-set conflicts, leading to a disastrous production.

The film's main issues stemmed from difficulties with actors like Val Kilmer and Marlon Brando, causing chaos on set.

A modern-day remake using CGI could bring the nightmarish tale of human-animal hybrids to life like never before.

The Island of Dr. Moreau (1996) is infamous for being one of the worst, if not the worst, Hollywood productions in cinematic history. The film underwent various challenges, from on-set conflicts to harsh weather conditions, and became notorious for its extremely difficult production. Cult horror director Richard Stanley was originally hired by New Line Cinema but was quickly replaced by John Frankenheimer after disasters arose in pre-production. The film was doomed to be a box-office flop upon its release in 1996, but the time may be right for a long-overdue, modern Hollywood remake.

Based on H.G. Wells' classic science-fiction novel about an island of human-animal hybrids, the 1996 adaptation of The Island of Dr. Moreau starred Val Kilmer as Edward Prendick and Marlon Brando as the titular mad scientist. However, both actors proved to be very hard to work with, contributing to the film's failure, along with a multitude of other reasons. The film later developed a cult following which, combined with the original novel's nightmarish themes, means that a modern remake of this sci-fi horror movie could be just what audiences desperately need from Hollywood.

What Went Wrong With Marlon Brando's The Island Of Dr. Moreau

The Shooting Location Encountered A Major Hurricane During Production

Close

The film's downfall was primarily due to professional and personal conflicts. Various cast and crew members left the production, including Bruce Willis, initially cast as Edward Prendick. Willis' withdrawal led to Kilmer joining the cast, whose problematic on-set behavior caused further issues. Kilmer wanted less dialogue and screen time, forcing Stanley to recast him as the supporting role of Montgomery, resulting in James Woods' departure. Problems further escalated when lead actor Rob Morrow unexpectedly dropped out on the second day of shooting, and on the third day, Stanley was fired as director and replaced by John Frankenheimer.

The film's production spawned a 2014 documentary chronicling the harrowing journey from beginning to end...

David Thewlis was subsequently cast in the lead role, but problems continued. Veteran Hollywood actor Marlon Brando slowed down filming by spending hours in his air-conditioned trailer and allegedly even having an on-set feud with Kilmer. Brando also refused to learn his lines, resulting in his assistant feeding him dialogue through a radio receiver. The film's production spawned a 2014 documentary, Lost Soul: The Doomed Journey of Richard Stanley’s Island of Dr. Moreau, chronicling the harrowing journey from beginning to end, reinforcing Hollywood's need to finally remake the film and do it justice.

Related Val Kilmer's Biggest Controversy: What Went Wrong With Island Of Dr. Moreau Val Kilmer took heat for the 1996 Island of Dr. Moreau's disastrous shoot, which included feuds with Marlon Brando and director John Frankenheimer.

Modern CGI Would Make A Remake Of The Island Of Dr. Moreau Even Scarier

The "Beast Folk" Were Created Through Scientific Experiments

In addition to pre-production challenges, one of the main reasons why The Island of Dr. Moreau bombed at the box-office was simply because it did not look good. In retrospect, the practical effects and costume design for Dr. Moreau's human-animal hybrids look extremely outdated and comical, especially compared to modern-day standards, making a high-budget Hollywood remake absolutely necessary to bring the story to life.

With contemporary creature features implementing realistically frightening CGI in films such as Splice (2008), Annihilation (2017), A Quiet Place (2018), perhaps it's time that Hollywood followed suit with The Island of Dr. Moreau. Modern CGI, combined with up-to-date practical effects, would create a far more grotesque and threatening version of the so-called "Beast Folk", aligning more with the nightmarish atmosphere of H.G. Wells' original novel.

The Island Of Dr. Moreau's Remake Could Do The H.G. Wells Book Justice

There Are Four Major Film Adaptations Of The Novel

Many themes from Wells' novel were explored in the '90s adaptation, although they were overshadowed by the film’s extremely poor reception. However, Hollywood could do Wells' novel justice by recreating a darker and grittier version, emphasizing the novel's prominent themes, such as the dangers of scientific pursuits and humanity's duality with beasts. A nuanced approach that explores these horror-induced existential themes would appeal to fans of the original novel, and through modern film-making techniques, would make The Island of Dr. Moreau even more relevant today.

The film's infamous backstory, cult status, and the novel's abundance of existential themes make The Island of Dr. Moreau the perfect target for a Hollywood remake...

Beyond the film's notorious reputation as Hollywood's worst production, the movie still stands as a cult favorite among lovers of schlocky '90s horror, as well as fans of the original novel. The film's infamous backstory, cult status, and the novel's abundance of existential themes makes The Island of Dr. Moreau the perfect target for a Hollywood remake that could potentially succeed in today's cinematic landscape.