Band Of Brothers Secretly Copied A Major Saving Private Ryan Mystery

Summary Band of Brothers copies Saving Private Ryan's captain mystery, emphasizing the importance of commanders remaining detached from their troops.

Both Winters and Miller are mysterious figures to their men, gradually opening up as they build trust.

Band of Brothers' approach is more realistic and effective in conveying the message of command in wartime.

HBO's Band of Brothers owes a clear debt to Stephen Spielberg's celebrated war movie, Saving Private Ryan. However, beyond subtle allusions to the 1997 Oscar-winner, the show also repeats almost verbatim one of the film's main mysteries. Such a narrative approach, irrespective of all the other similarities between the projects, creates a fascinating parallel that warrants further analysis.

Focusing on the exploits of Easy Company during the Second World War, Band of Brothers is in many ways an expanded alternative to the story told in Saving Private Ryan. Starting with the Normandy invasion, the show follows Easy as they campaign through Europe, depicting the company's hardships, triumphs, and experiences of warfare. As well as brutal battle scenes, Band of Brothers also showcases intimate moments that reveal much about individual soldiers' characters. It's in these scenes that the show is revealed to have copied a major idea from Saving Private Ryan.

Related 10 Things I Learned Rewatching Band Of Brothers In 2024 Band of Brothers remains one of the all-time great TV series. Rewatching the show reveals some things that still hold up, and some that don't.

Band Of Brothers Copies Saving Private Ryan's Captain Mystery

Both Winters And Miller Are A Mystery To Their Men

Close

In Band of Brothers episode 2, "Day of Days", Dick Winters is seen walking through a courtyard in the aftermath of a grueling battle to take the German guns at Brécourt Manor. From the back of a truck, he hears voices of fellow soldiers from Easy Company, with Guanere hypothesizing that the reason Winters doesn't drink is that "he's a Quaker". Having previously remained distant from the men, he decides to join them, accepting their offer of a drink, before telling Guanere that he's not a Quaker. It's a powerful moment that signifies the growing bond between the men of Easy.

In their aloofness and gradual openness with their men, the fictional Miller and real Winters are revealed to be extremely similar characters...

Beyond this, however, the mystery around Winters' background, his religion, and possible reasons for not drinking are a direct reflection of a similar mystery in Saving Private Ryan. In the movie, there is a company bet on the background of Captain Miller (Tom Hanks), with various soldiers desperately trying to unearth the secret in order to win a company pool. In their aloofness and gradual openness with their men, the fictional Miller and real Winters are revealed to be extremely similar characters, with both stories using almost identical devices to reveal more about their characters.

What The Captain Mystery Means In Both Projects

It's Subtly Different Between The Two Stories

It's significant that both Band of Brothers and Saving Private Ryan choose to emphasize the Captains' remoteness from their men. Although both Winters and Miller command huge respect for their skills on the battlefield, the fact that they choose to remain distant is a way for both stories to show that, in war, commanders should not be friends with their troops. Instead, they need to remain relatively detached, since becoming too emotionally involved might cloud their judgment on the battlefield.

In Saving Private Ryan, this reality is more subtly inferred, with the mystery around Miller more of a long-running joke than a tactical necessity. However, Band of Brothers highlights why such apparent coldness is absolutely essential. When Buck and Winters have some time away from their men, Winters reprimands Buck for gambling with the troops, asking him directly "what if you'd won" and telling him to "never be in a position where you can take from these men". This apparent strictness highlights the responsibility that figures like Miller and Winters have in times of warfare.

Related 8 Harsh Realities Of Rewatching Band Of Brothers, 23 Years Later Band of Brothers is one of the all-time great television series, but over 20 years on, it's clear some things have held up better than others.

Band Of Brothers' Captain Mystery Is More Realistic

The Message Remains The Same

Although both Saving Private Ryan and Band of Brothers are trying to convey the same message about command by including a captain mystery, Band of Brothers' approach is both more realistic and effective. In Saving Private Ryan, Miller remains completely remote until a moment of crisis for his men when they're on the verge of mutiny. It makes for a powerful dramatic moment, but feels somewhat confected in the broader context of war.

Band of Brothers is available to stream on Max and Netflix.

Band of Brothers, on the other hand, does a much more effective job of switching perspectives between ordinary soldiers and their commanders, highlighting the psychological toll placed on both. In some scenes, Winters seems an almost impossibly heroic figure, setting an example for his men by his ruthless stoicism. However, in scenes such as the one in episode 2, it's clear that his distance is, as he sees it, a tragic necessity – preventing him from becoming too emotionally detached and allowing him to act rationally. It's an understated but fascinating insight into what command is really like.