Star Wars Fans Hate Jar Jar Binks But That's Because His Best Moment Never Made It to Film

Jar Jar Binks is one of the most despised characters in Star Wars history, and it’s not because he’s a despicable, irredeemable villain, but because many fans simply find him insufferably annoying. But, if one moment from the comics made it into the film, it’s likely Star Wars fans wouldn’t hate Jar Jar Binks so much.

In Star Wars: The Phantom Menace 25th Anniversary Special by Greg Pak and Will Sliney, fans are shown the events of Episode I just as they played out in the original movie, but with a few extra scenes added to more fully flesh out those events. Among the many added scenes were a vision Anakin had of becoming a Jedi before even meeting Qui-Gon or Obi-Wan, a scene where Anakin saves the life of a Tusken Raider, and a tender moment between Anakin and Jar Jar Binks right after Anakin stood before the Jedi Council for the first time.

Close

In that scene, Anakin Skywalker is sitting alone in the Jedi Temple, saddened by the news that the Jedi Council would not permit Qui-Gon Jinn to train Anakin as a Jedi. Anakin is then approached by Jar Jar Binks, and rather than being a chaotic mess for the sake of a cheap laugh, Jar Jar actually comes off as a strong and kind character. Jar Jar relates to Anakin’s experience of being denied and dismissed, before telling Anakin that he has a good heart, and that everything will be fine.

Star Wars Fans Need to See Jar Jar Binks in a More Serious Light

Jar Jar Binks Clearly Doesn’t Work as a Comedic Character

When Jar Jar Binks was introduced, he was meant to be funny, but instead he came off as incredibly annoying - and it’s easy to see how. Jar Jar bumbled through every scene he was in, breaking things left and right, and just creating chaos wherever he went. Even during high-stakes scenes in the film, Jar Jar’s unyielding buffoonery persisted, making the viewing experience frustrating for fans.

Obviously, comedy isn’t working for Jar Jar Binks. This scene in the Anniversary Special comic confirms that Jar Jar can actually be a serious character - or, at least have more serious moments. All the annoying antics he got into in The Phantom Menace could have been forgiven if this scene made it into the original film. It would have shown that there is more to Jar Jar than his absurd ‘comedic’ moments, and it would have made his relationship with Anakin much more significant.

1 Scene May Not Be Enough to Redeem Jar Jar Binks in Star Wars

Some Star Wars Fans Hate Jar Jar Binks for Another Reason

While Jar Jar Binks’ moment with Anakin in this comic is a nice addition to his character that serves to offshoot his more annoying qualities, it might not be enough to redeem him. As the Star Wars prequels went on, Jar Jar became a political figure representing the Gungans on Naboo, meaning he had political influence in the galaxy. In fact, it was Jar Jar who convinced the senate to extend the Emergency Powers Act in Episode III, effectively paving the way for Supreme Chancellor Palpatine to become Emperor Palpatine.

Related After 47 Years, Star Wars Has Finally Figured Out How To Avoid The "Tatooine Trap" Star Wars: Skeleton Crew is expanding the galaxy in more ways than one. When was the last time a Star Wars project explored so many diverse worlds?

Jar Jar Binks literally played a role in the rise of the Empire, and while he wasn’t the sole cause, his stupidity helped throw the galaxy into a Sith-ruled dictatorship. A tender moment with Anakin Skywalker may fix one aspect of why Jar Jar Binks is despised, but nothing can fix the pain and suffering he helped cause across the galaxy. But, his politics aren’t the reason Star Wars fans hate Jar Jar Binks, they hate him because they find him annoying, which is something that’s fixed with this one added scene.